Amy’s Hardware & Music isn’t just a store. It’s a place where a drill bit and a disco ball can peacefully coexist… and somehow make perfect sense.

Located in the heart of Sag Harbor, our shop blends the practical with the unexpected. You’ll find Benjamin Moore paint, tools, and grilling essentials right alongside guitars, percussion instruments, crystals, candles, and the occasional sparkly object that makes you stop and smile. It’s hardware, reimagined with a little rhythm.

This store carries a legacy. Originally a neighborhood hardware staple for decades, it was entrusted to Amy—who saw not just what it was, but what it could become. Over the past few years, she’s transformed it into a vibrant, creative space where people come not only to fix things… but to feel something.

We believe a great store should be useful, yes—but also inspiring. A place where you come in for a lightbulb and leave with a guitar pick, a story, and maybe a reason to come back later that night for live music under a spinning disco ball.

At Amy’s, we work hard. We play loud. And we welcome everyone